The battle between Leyton Robinson and Manny Costello on The Voice Season 28 officially became the most-watched of the season, racking up over 8 million views. But despite the performance’s record-breaking popularity, it was Manny who was sent home—a decision that left fans frustrated and pleading for a powerful callback.
Night 3 of the Battle Rounds featured Team Reba’s two rising country singers going head-to-head with Chris Stapleton’s “Think I’m In Love With You.” Both contestants delivered a soulful, emotional performance filled with chemistry, harmonies, and stunning vocal moments that had the coaches praising them throughout.
During rehearsals, Reba noted that both artists brought something unique to the table, encouraging them to strengthen their harmonies. Guest advisor Nick Jonas suggested Leyton add a “flutter” to the end of her lines, while Reba emphasized blending and control.
When it came time for the performance, Manny impressed with his rich, raspy tone and heartfelt delivery, while Leyton showcased a pure, piercing tone that stood out with power and clarity.
Coach Michael Bublé praised both singers, saying, “Leyton could sing the phone book, but I also love the gravel in Manny’s voice. It’s so hard to choose.” He later admitted, “My hands are sweaty… I almost did it. I chickened out.” Snoop Dogg called the duet “beautiful” and said both artists brought “something special.” Niall Horan added that the two “stepped it up big time.”
Reba ultimately chose Leyton Robinson as the winner, saying, “Leyton and Manny are two of my favorites. I absolutely love them. I chose Leyton because I think I can help her. I’m so impressed with her vocals, and I want to give her songs that challenge her—I think she’ll rise to the occasion.” Unfortunately, Manny Costello was sent home after no other coaches opted to steal him.
Fans quickly reacted online, expressing outrage over the decision. Many argued that Reba made the wrong call and that Manny “won that one.” Comments included:
“Manny won that one… no steal either? What are you thinking?”
“Idk what Reba is thinking!! Manny won that hands down!!!”
“I cannot believe Reba chose her over Manny! He was my favorite on the song. There’s a dozen or more singers like Leyton in country music today already. Boo Reba!”
“BEST duet on The Voice in many years! Unbelievable they let him go home. WOW!”
Across The Voice’s official social media pages, dozens of viewers shared disappointment that no one saved Manny:
“He deserves to move on to the next level.”
“Bring Manny Back!!!”
“Shocked they sent the best singer on the show home.”
“Manny could’ve won this whole thing! What were they thinking letting him go home???”
Many agreed that Manny’s unique, textured voice stood out. Comments included:
“If I heard his voice on the radio, I’d know it was him. So beautiful, so sad he’s out.”
Hashtags like #BringMannyBack were widely shared, with fans calling for a wildcard return, referencing previous seasons where eliminated contestants were brought back later.
Despite the disappointment, fans praised the performance as one of the best of the season:
“This was a phenomenal performance!! Both are amazing. Sad he wasn’t saved or stolen.”
With over 20,000 comments pleading for a callback, the demand for a second chance for Manny Costello has become impossible to ignore.
After the show, Manny took to social media to share his thoughts:
*”What a WILD ride! So blessed to be a part of this show and forever grateful for the people it has put in my life. Praise God—through Him and Him alone is all this possible.
Congratulations to my partner @leytonrobinsonn—you crushed it! Can’t wait to see your next episode.
HUGE thanks to all of you who have supported me on my journey. I’m overwhelmed, to say the least.
This is just the beginning—we’re only getting started…”*
