free hit counter Two Contestants Sent Home After American Idol Judges Deliver Tough Comments and Big Praise on Taylor Swift Night - FRESH

Two Contestants Sent Home After American Idol Judges Deliver Tough Comments and Big Praise on Taylor Swift Night

The Top 7 celebrated Taylor Swift on the April 27 episode of American Idol. The remaining contestants all sang songs from Swift’s catalogue, and also saluted California’s biggest artists throughout the night.

Nikki Glaser joined the judges’ panel alongside Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood, and Lionel Richie to give the artists commentary and critiques. However, the power was in the hands of the viewers, who got to vote for their favorites over the course of the live episode.

At the end of the night, the two singers with the lowest amount of votes will be eliminated, leaving just five contestants to move on to next week. Scroll down for live updates of the performances and check back at the end of the show to find out who’s going home and who’s heading to the Top 5!

Jordan McCullough

Jordan McCullough kicked off the night by performing Swift’s first-ever single “Tim McGraw” from her debut album, released 20 years ago in 2006.

Jordan McCullough

“That is the way to put barbecue sauce on Taylor Swift,” Richie began. “I am telling you, that was so well done. You put the curls in, I just love that. I can’t even hit that note. I loved everything you did.”

Underwood applauded the fact that Jordan sounds “beautiful on everything” he sings, and Glaser gushed, “I am so grateful I just got to hear you sing live. It feels like a real privilege to listen to you.”

Chris Tungseth

Chris Tungseth chose to sing Swift and Bon Iver’s collaboration “Exile,” which is on her 2020 album Folklore.

Chris Tungseth

Underwood commented on the “tender quality” of Chris’ voice. “I think you picked a really great song to showcase that,” she added, while Glaser said she got goosebumps throughout the entire performance.

“I love that you were really locked in on that. You had me focused and locked in,” Bryan raved. “I loved your character, the way you delivered the song, you had your own imagery and character that you created.” Finally, Richie said it was one of his favorite performances of Chris’ from the entire season and said the delivery was “spot on.”

Hannah Harper

Hannah Harper took things back to Speak Now to perform Swift’s Grammy-winning hit “Mean.” And she even broke out the banjo for her performance!

Hannah Harper

Glaser praised Hannah for her song choice after dealing with criticism for her performance two weeks ago. Bryan said Hannah is “being authentically you” and agreed that the song choice was “great.”

Richie added, “This is how you do it. You’re true to yourself. You don’t come out as a gimmick. You come out true to who you are,” and Underwood said she “loved everything about this performance,” from the look to the banjo and more.

Brooks Rosser

Brooks Rosser honored Swift’s Fearless era with a performance of “Love Story.” Considering he launched his own love story on the show just last week, this was the perfect song for the night!

Brooks Rosser

“I just love hearing your interpretation of that,” Bryan raved, but also advised, “Just force yourself to always give more energy. You took that energy up there at the end, but I just wanted a little more.”

Richie said he’s “enjoying” seeing Brooks “having a great time” on stage. “Your voice is so unique. The storyteller part of that voice you have is so fitting for the song you just did,” he continued, but also gave some advice on how to “give some attitude” in his performances.

Underwood made sure to let Brooks know that everyone “loves him,” but urged him to “just breathe” so he’s not trying to catch up with his songs moving forward. “I know it will just come with time, but just breathe and sync into it and let it come out of you,” she shared.

Daniel Stallworth

The Taylor Swift celebration continued with a performance from Daniel Stallworth, who sang “Fearless” with his own gospel twist.

Daniel Stallworth

“What I love about you is that you walk out on this stage … and you picked the right song, you are fearless, man, when you walk out,” Richie gushed. “You not only sing, you perform. The crowd is right there with you.”

Underwood praised Daniel for putting his own stamp on the theme, and Glaser added, “You brought something totally different to it. I just had the best time watching you.”

Keyla Richardson

For her Taylor Swift performance, Keyla Richardson sang “Lover,” another title track. “We do not ever have to worry about you,” Underwood admitted. “We just get to sit back and watch you perform. Your melodic choices … you impress me every single week.”

Glaser said she couldn’t even recognize the song because Keyla “brought something new to it I didn’t even know could be brought to it!” She also applauded her for making it “look so easy” when she’s on stage. “I’m honestly speechless,” she added.

Meanwhile, Bryan raved over Keyla’s confidence. “It’s become kind of your thing,” he said. “To watch you, week after week, get even more confidence and deliver that message … everything is channeling perfectly for you. So proud of you.”

Braden Rumfelt

The final performance from the first round was from Braden Rumfelt, who sang “Cardigan” from Folklore.

Braden Rumfelt

Glaser told Braden he “ate that song,” despite not knowing it before he chose it to sing on the show. “You took me there with the music. It was really, really beautiful,” she confirmed.

Bryan said it was his “favorite thing” he’s seen Braden do in the entire competition so far. “You totally took me on the emotional journey of that song. I loved it, man,” he raved.

Brooks Rosser

Brooks returned to the stage for his next performance with a rendition of Maroon 5’s “She Will Be Loved.”

Brooks Rosser

Bryan said Brooks was “locked in” compared to the last round and noted that the song choice was perfect for his voice. Richie said, “Ditto, ditto, ditto” to everything Bryan commented on. “Perfect song for you, you did such a great job,” he added.

Underwood gushed over Brooks’ “magical voice” from the very first note and said it was a “very solid performance.”

Jordan McCullough

Jordan’s second performance was of Bonnie Raitt’s “I Can’t Make You Love Me,” and he said he was hoping to hit California energy on stage.

Jordan McCullough

“I have heard that song a long time … you got me crying on that song that I heard for a long time. Your delivery was right on point,” Richie told Jordan.

Underwood agreed, adding, “I don’t care what you sing. Every time you open your mouth, I hear the holy spirit.” She called his voice “truly blessed” and said it’s one of the best voices she’s ever heard “in my entire life.”

Daniel Stallworth

For his second performance of the night, Daniel performed “Best Part” by H.E.R and Daniel Caesar. He also played piano for part of the set.

Daniel Stallworth

Underwood compared Daniel’s voice to “like butter on hot toast” and said the performance was great. Glaser praised his “versatility” and said she can already envision a “whole show” from him.

Richie and Bryan noted that they’ve never even heard some of the notes Daniel was hitting and Richie called the performance “amazing.”

Braden Rumfelt

Like Brooks, Braden also sang a Maroon 5 classic for the second round. He hoped to prove he was having fun during his performance of “This Love.”

Braden Rumfelt

“You owned that. It felt cool, you look cool. … I loved the whole thing,” Glaser praised. Bryan said it was a “great job” by Braden and Richie applauded the singer for upping his performance factor.

“It was such a great moment for you. You look like a rockstar. You seem more comfortable than I feel like I’ve ever seen you be on stage and it was just working,” Underwood added.

Chris Tungseth

Chris sang Billie Eilish’s “What Was I Made For?”, which he said is one of his favorite songs.

Chris Tungseth

“Really special, beautiful moment. That’s twice tonight you have slayed us with those moments,” Bryan noted, while Richie said, “For a song that needs so much feeling, I think you felt it, and you made us feel it. Great performance, man.”

Underwood called it a “moment” and admitted she felt like she was at an awards show watching Chris. Finally, Glaser, said, simply, “What were you made for? That. That.”

Hannah Harper

Hannah’s second performance was of Merle Haggard’s “That’s the Way Love Goes.” She felt it was a “fitting song,” as she honored her husband with the choice.

Hannah harper

“That was absolutely amazing. You are looking like a star, you sounded like a star … I guess you’re getting close to that big star,” Richie said. Underwood urged Hannah to make a “proper version” of that performance. “It sounded like you and it was just wonderful,” she gushed.

Glaser compared the performance to a “warm blanket” and Bryan admitted, “If you want to, you’re going to get to do this for a very long time, this singing thing. You’re just a star.”

Keyla Richardson

The final performance of the night was from Keyla, who returned to the stage to sing Etta James’ “I’d Rather Go Blind.”

Keyla Richardson

The judges could barely get a word in because the crowd erupted with applause that was never-ending. “That was insane. That was an iconic Idol moment,” Glaser confirmed.

“Watching your growth is so inspirational,” Bryan added, and all Richie had to say was, “Let the congregation say AMEN!”

Ryan Seacrest announced the five singers who will be moving on to next week, where they will be mentored by Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul, two of Idol’s original judges.

The singers in the Top 5 (in no particular order) are: Keyla Richardson, Braden Rumfelt, Jordan McCullough, Hannah Harper, and Chris Tungseth.

Who was eliminated?

The two artists who were eliminated at the end of the April 27 episode were: Brooks Rosser and Daniel Stallworth

Keep refreshing throughout the episode because we’ll be updating with live updates from the show…

American Idol, Season 24, Mondays, 8/7c

Related Posts

The President Just Turned 80 — and They Threw the Wildest UFC Event in History Right on the White House South Lawn

WASHINGTON — UFC Freedom 250 on the White House South Lawn was a knockout, in more ways than one. All seven of the fights on Sunday night’s…

IT’S IN THE DETAILS, BABY.” – Zac Brown’s Patriotic UFC Freedom 250 Outfit Had One Hidden Detail Almost Everyone Missed — And Once Fans Saw What Was Secretly Sewn Inside His Jacket, The Internet Couldn’t Stop Talking About It.

Zac Brown went all out for UFC Freedom 250, and fans are just now realizing that his suit was oozing with patriotism. The frontman of the Zac Brown…

50 YEARS AGO, 7 COLLEGE KIDS STARTED ACTING IN AN 88-SEAT CHURCH BASEMENT. LAST NIGHT, ONE OF THEM HELD HER 3RD TONY. Laurie Metcalf just won Best Featured Actress in a Play at the 79th Tony Awards for her role as Linda Loman in Death of a Salesman — alongside Nathan Lane, directed by Joe Mantello. This is her 3rd Tony. Her 7th nomination. But what she did at Radio City Music Hall wasn’t about the numbers. She stood up there and named 6 people. Not agents. Not producers. Six college friends from Illinois State University who started Steppenwolf Theatre together — in a church basement. Gary Sinise. John Malkovich. Jeff Perry. Terry Kinney. Moira Harris. Al Wilder. “I still consider them family,” she said. “I still draw on lessons I learned from them.” After everything — the Emmys, the Oscar nomination, decades on Roseanne — the first people she thanked were the ones who knew her before any of it mattered. Some things don’t change, even after 50 years.

Laurie Metcalf’s Third Tony Was Never Just About the Award Last night at Radio City Music Hall, Laurie Metcalf added another major chapter to a career already…

THEY FIRED HIM ON A TUESDAY. BY SATURDAY, HE WAS SMILING ON A SAILBOAT. Scott Pelley spent 37 years at CBS News. He anchored the Evening News. He reported from war zones. He won dozens of Emmys. And last week, on his new boss’s very first day, he stood up in a staff meeting and said what nobody else would. He told executive producer Nick Bilton he’d “never be welcome here.” He accused CBS chief Bari Weiss of “murdering” 60 Minutes. But what Pelley claimed they asked him to do behind the scenes — that part changes everything. Within 24 hours, he was handed a termination letter. Fired “for cause.” 37 years, gone in a single page. Then Saturday morning, he posted a photo on Instagram. No anger. Just him at the helm of a sailboat, hands on the wheel, American flag behind him, looking out at open water. His only words: “You are the wind in my sails. So deeply grateful.”

They Fired Scott Pelley on a Tuesday. By Saturday, He Was Smiling on a Sailboat It is hard to imagine a cleaner break from a newsroom than…

Pink soars into Broadway’s biggest night facing the same doubts that have followed her for years, but one breathtaking opening number turns uncertainty into pure spectacle.

For decades, Pink built a career around proving she belonged in rooms where many people never expected to see her. From pop stardom to aerial performances that…

GOLDEN TEMPO DID IT AGAIN FROM 12 LENGTHS BACK TO BELMONT GLORY, HE JUST TURNED ANOTHER IMPOSSIBLE COMEBACK INTO HISTORY. 🏇🔥Five weeks after storming from last to first in the Kentucky Derby, Golden Tempo walked into the 2026 Belmont Stakes with one question hanging over him: Was the Derby magic real? Then he answered it in the stretch.

Golden Tempo wins 2026 Belmont Stakes with another late comeback Golden Tempo showed exactly why he is a great closer, and his stretch run at the Belmont…