American Idol may be heading toward a milestone season in 2027, but uncertainty around its future has also put renewed attention on its judging panel, especially Carrie Underwood, who is navigating both on-screen reactions and behind-the-scenes frustrations.

ABC has yet to officially confirm whether the show will return for a 25th season, though strong ratings from the current run suggest a continuation is likely. The long-running competition, which originally aired on Fox before being revived by ABC in 2018, continues to perform well in viewership, ranking among the network’s top-rated programs.

While discussions about the next season continue, Underwood’s role on the panel has drawn increased scrutiny. According to reports, the country superstar has been “frustrated” this season after producers repeatedly highlighted moments in which she was booed by the studio audience. Insiders claim the editing choices leaned into those reactions for dramatic effect, something Underwood reportedly viewed as unfair.

“She’s felt more frustrated and annoyed by some of the producers’ decisions this season,” a source said, adding that producers were “making a mockery” of her by showcasing the boos.

Despite that, Underwood has remained composed publicly, even addressing the audience directly during a Hollywood Week taping when she anticipated negative reactions to her critique of a contestant. She acknowledged the boos in real time, leaning into the moment while maintaining her feedback.

Underwood, who joined the judging panel in Season 23 alongside veterans Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, has continued into Season 24 with a more outspoken presence. Sources say her approach has shifted compared to her debut season, becoming more confident and direct in her critiques.

As for the future, if American Idol returns in 2027, the judging lineup is expected to remain unclear until closer to production. With no official announcements yet, Underwood’s continued involvement remains an open question—leaving fans to wonder whether she will return for another season or if changes could be on the horizon.